Skip to Main Content
Boatwright Memorial Library
Boatwright Library
LibGuides
LLC 140: How to Write Everything
Evaluating Sources for Quality
Getting Started
Finding Articles and Books
U. S. and International News Sources
Writing and Citing
Evaluating Sources for Quality
Humanities Librarian
Marcia Whitehead
Email Me
Contact:
Boatwright Library
28 Westhampton Way
804-289-8823
Subjects:
American Studies
,
Biography
,
Book Reviews
,
Citing Sources
,
Classical Studies
,
E-Books
,
English & Literature
,
First Year Seminar
,
French
,
German
,
Humanities
,
International Education
,
Language and Linguistics
,
Languages, Literatures, and Cultures
,
Latin American, Latino, and Iberian Studies
,
Master of Liberal Arts
,
Primary Resources
,
Reference Sources
,
Rhetoric & Communication Studies
,
Richmond Area
,
Russian
,
Scholarly Publications
,
Spanish
,
Special Topics
Characteristics of Scholarly & Popular Articles:
Popular Articles
Scholarly Articles
Are often written by journalists or professional writers for a general audience rather than scholars
Informational, rather than original research
Uses language easily understood by general readers
Articles tend to be shorter
Rarely give full citations for a source -- may be referenced in the article, or not at all
Advertisements unrelated to contents -- glossy photos
Most written by or for academics, researchers or scholars
Uses scholarly or technical language
Tend to be longer articles about research or research findings
Includes full citations for sources, extensive bibliographies or reference lists
Are often refereed or peer reviewed
Few advertisements or color photos. Advertisements related to contents, such as other academic publications or subscriptions
Scholarly vs. Popular
Yale College Writing Center.
Distinguishing Scholarly Journals from Other Periodicals
Cornell University Library - provides useful breakdown of periodical sources for evaluation: scholarly, substantive news/general interest, popular, sensational.
Critical Evaluation for All Sources
Critical Evaluation of Resources (UC Berkely Library)
Critically Analyzing Information Sources (Cornell University Library)
<<
Previous:
Writing and Citing